If you've cleaned a white crust off a faucet aerator in Smithville or heard your water heater start to rumble, you've seen hard water at work. Smithville's water isn't the hardest around, but it's hard enough to matter for some appliances. This guide covers what's in the water, what a softener does about it, and how to size one so it isn't too big or too small for your house.
How hard is Smithville's tap water?
Smithville's tap water comes from Lake Ontario. Niagara Region treats it at the Grimsby Water Treatment Plant, and the Township of West Lincoln's Smithville distribution system brings it to your house. The same plant also serves Grimsby and parts of Lincoln.
Niagara Region lists the hardness of water from the Grimsby plant at 113 mg/L, from a sample taken on October 5, 2026. Hardness is mostly dissolved calcium and magnesium. On the usual scales, 113 mg/L counts as moderately hard: more than soft water, well short of the very hard water you get from some wells.
Most softeners and test strips use grains per gallon, not milligrams per litre. To convert, divide by about 17.1. That makes Smithville's water roughly 6.6 grains per gallon. Keep that number handy, because you'll need it for sizing.
If you're on a well or cistern outside the village or out toward Wellandport, none of this applies to you. Your hardness depends on your own well and can be quite different. The Township hands out testing kits for wells and cisterns at Town Hall, and Public Health Ontario tests those samples for bacteria at no charge. That test doesn't cover chemicals, though, and hardness isn't part of it. For hardness and iron you'll need a separate test before choosing a softener.
What does hard water do in a Smithville house?
Calcium and magnesium stay dissolved in cold water. When the water is heated or left to dry, they come out as scale. That's why most of the trouble shows up in these places:
- Tank water heaters. Scale settles on the bottom of the tank. On a gas heater it insulates the bottom from the burner, which makes the popping or rumbling you hear when it fires. On an electric heater it builds up on the lower element.
- Tankless water heaters. Water runs through a small heat exchanger, and scale narrows it. These units are the most sensitive to hardness, and their manuals usually say how often to descale.
- Faucet aerators, shower heads and toilet fill valves. These get crusted, so you see weaker flow and a tank that keeps topping itself up.
- Dishwashers, kettles and glassware. You get white film and spots.
Some problems get blamed on hard water when something else is at fault. If you have low pressure in a pre-war house around Griffin Street or Station Street, the cause is more often the old galvanized steel water line rusting shut from the inside, and a softener won't fix that. Pinhole leaks in the copper of a post-war house north of Townline Road have their own causes, and a softener isn't the cure for them either. In the newer Northwest Quadrant houses, the PEX lines hold up well against scale, so the water heater and fixtures are where hardness shows.
What does a water softener do?
A household softener is a tank of resin beads. As hard water passes through, the beads hold onto the calcium and magnesium and let go of sodium (or potassium, if you use that salt) in their place. Water that comes out has little hardness left, so it doesn't leave scale.
When the beads are full, the softener regenerates. It draws salty water from the brine tank, flushes the hardness off the beads and sends that rinse water down the drain. Then it's ready again. Most current units decide when to regenerate by measuring how much water has gone through them. Older ones run on a timer whether you've used much water or not.
A softener only deals with scale. It doesn't make water safer to drink, and it doesn't remove bacteria, lead or most other contaminants.
Is a softener worth it at 113 mg/L?
It depends mostly on what you own.
- If you have a tankless water heater, a softener is worth considering seriously. It cuts down on descaling and protects the heat exchanger. Read the manufacturer warranty, too. Some set limits on water hardness, and that can matter if you ever need to make a claim.
- If you have a tank water heater and the spots and crust don't bother you, you can often manage without one. Flush the tank once a year and soak aerators and shower heads in vinegar when they crust up. Plenty of Smithville households do just that.
- If you're on a well with high hardness or iron, a softener, or a softener with iron treatment, usually earns its keep.
A softener costs money to buy and install, and it needs salt for as long as you have it. Weigh that against how often you're descaling and how soon your water heater might need replacing.
How do you size a softener?
Sizing comes down to how much hardness the softener has to remove between regenerations. You don't need a salesperson's chart to work it out. You need four things:
- Your hardness in grains per gallon. On town water that's about 6.6. For a well, use your own test result, and if the test shows iron, ask how to account for it, because iron uses up softener capacity too.
- Your daily water use. Your water bill shows how much the house used over the billing period. Divide by the number of days to get a daily figure, then convert to US gallons, since softener ratings use them.
- How often you want it to regenerate. About once a week is a common target. Regenerating less often than that isn't good for the resin, and regenerating every day wastes salt and water.
- The softener's capacity at the salt setting you'll actually use. Softeners are sold by grain capacity, but the headline number usually assumes a heavy salt setting. At a moderate setting the real capacity is lower, so ask for the capacity at the setting you plan to run.
The arithmetic is short. Multiply daily gallons by grains per gallon to get grains removed per day. Multiply that by the number of days between regenerations. Choose a unit whose capacity at a moderate salt setting covers that total, with a little room to spare.
A unit that's too small regenerates constantly and goes through salt. One that's far too big regenerates so rarely that the resin sits idle. On town water at moderate hardness, most single-family houses don't need a large unit, and households that have one were often sold on the label rather than the arithmetic.
What should the installation look like?
The softener belongs on the main water line, after the meter and the main shut-off, near a drain and an electrical outlet. A few details make the difference between a good install and a nuisance:
- A bypass valve, so the house still has water when the unit is being serviced.
- A hard cold tap at the kitchen sink, if you want drinking and cooking water without the added sodium. People on a low-sodium diet should ask their doctor whether they need one. Outdoor taps are usually left hard as well, since there's no point softening water for the garden.
- A proper air gap on the drain line, so regeneration water can't be drawn back into the softener.
- A dry spot that doesn't freeze. Smithville sees around 121 days a year with a low at or below 0 °C, so a softener in an unheated garage or crawl space is asking for trouble.
New plumbing on the water line can need a building permit. The Township's building department can tell you whether your job does.
Once it's in, check the brine tank every month or so and top up the salt. If you notice a hard crust bridging across the salt, break it up. The tank can look full while the water underneath has stopped dissolving any salt.
If scale has already got into your water heater, or you're choosing a new heater with a softener in mind, see our water heaters page.